The Grief Machine - Decipon Insights

The Post

One post. One sentence. One death that didn’t happen.

“The entire family mourns as they announce the passing of South Sydney Rabbitohs legend Nathan Merritt, who passed away at the age of 42.”

Nathan Merritt was alive. He had publicly confirmed a stage four cancer diagnosis weeks earlier. The post appeared on a page called “Bunny Spirit Rugby,” which Facebook’s Page Transparency data confirmed was operated from Vietnam. The post included an AI-generated image. Below it, in the comments, a link. The link led to a website strewn with advertisements.

Merritt’s community — Redfern All Blacks, the club associated with the South Sydney neighbourhood he’d played for — issued a correction on Instagram. “Nathan has not passed away. These reports are completely false.”

The correction is the tell. Without it, no one was coming. The grief just ran.

The Network

Between March and May 2026, a coordinated network of fake Facebook pages fabricated player deaths, terminal illnesses, LGBTQ+ controversies, and family tragedies targeting fans of Australian and New Zealand rugby clubs.

NRL clubs targeted: South Sydney Rabbitohs, Penrith Panthers, Sydney Roosters, Melbourne Storm, Brisbane Broncos, New Zealand Warriors. AFL clubs also hit. New Zealand Super Rugby followed.

Page names included: Bunny Spirit Rugby, Redfern Spirit Circle, Storm Surge Squad, Red Knight Legacy, Warrior Spirit NZ.

Facebook’s Page Transparency data — the system that ostensibly provides accountability by revealing who operates a page — confirmed Vietnamese and Filipino operators across multiple pages. The transparency mechanism disclosed the location. The pages ran anyway.

The AI-generated images carried Google Gemini watermarks and SynthID markers. Visible to anyone who looked. The condolence comments accumulated anyway.

What the Machine Made

Nathan Merritt — stage four cancer, alive — declared dead.

Julian Savea — All Blacks winger — his wife declared dead. More than 100 condolence comments appeared before corrections reached the thread.

Dan Carter — declared hospitalized, “fighting for his life.”

Roger Tuivasa-Sheck — Warriors star — falsely credited with a $500,000 donation to the family of a deceased child.

Andrew Webster — Warriors coach — placed on a fabricated TIME magazine cover, then in a fabricated surgical recovery post.

A Crusaders staff member, falsely killed. A child, falsely killed. A staged fire at Sky Stadium.

All Blacks first five-eighth Richie Mo’unga falsely shown in a Penrith Panthers shirt, attributed inflammatory comments about LGBTQ+ themes in children’s media.

The pattern is consistent: emotionally devastating content, maximized for shares and comments, connected in the comments to an external link leading somewhere with a lot of advertising.

The Business Model

This is not state propaganda. There is no political objective. The operation carries no flag, advances no ideology, serves no handler in an intelligence directorate.

It is a content farm with a grief vertical.

AI tools — available free or cheaply — generate images and text. The images carry watermarks but look convincing at scroll speed. The text mimics local fan page language. The content is calibrated to produce the highest-engagement emotional responses: death, illness, family tragedy, community outrage.

High engagement means shares. Shares mean the post appears in feeds. Feeds deliver the post to people who didn’t follow the page. Some of those people click the link in the comments. The link delivers ad revenue. The cycle repeats.

The marginal cost per post is negligible. The marginal revenue per thousand clicks — distributed across a network of ad-laden pages across two countries and multiple clubs — is sufficient to make the operation worth running.

This is disinformation as a business, not as a weapon.

Why Rugby, Why These Communities

The choice of rugby league and union in Australia and New Zealand is not random. It is audience selection.

Rugby league in South Sydney, in Western Sydney, in South Auckland — these are communities where the local club is not entertainment. It is identity. Players are known by name across generations. Former players remain woven into neighbourhood life. A man like Nathan Merritt, who played for Redfern for nearly two decades and whose cancer diagnosis was publicly known, is not just a sports figure to Rabbitohs fans. His illness was real. Declaring him dead inserts fabricated grief into a real grief community.

The Richie Mo’unga fabrication targets a different pressure point. Pacific Island rugby culture is deeply connected to Christian faith communities. A fake quote attributed to Mo’unga about LGBTQ+ content in children’s media is designed to trigger moral outrage in communities where that topic is already a live tension. The goal is not to mislead about Mo’unga specifically. The goal is to harvest the engagement that moral outrage generates — comments, shares, replies — and convert that engagement into traffic.

Identity salience is the operating principle: find what the community cares about most deeply, generate content that threatens it, harvest the response.

The Geographic Pivot

The New Zealand operation launched while the Australian pages were still running, before any meaningful platform intervention had landed.

The operators were not reacting to pressure. They were expanding before pressure arrived. By the time the leagues and Meta began working to pull the pages down, the New Zealand rugby operation was already up. The network was mobile before anyone noticed it was moving.

This tells you something about the model. Individual pages — Bunny Spirit Rugby, Warrior Spirit NZ — are disposable. A terminated page is a cost, not a loss. The knowledge of which content works, which communities respond, which emotional triggers convert to clicks: that stays with the operators. The next page starts with everything the previous one learned.

Facebook Page Transparency confirmed where the pages were operated. That confirmation did not close the pages. “Red Knight Legacy” was created April 6, renamed April 15, and continued operating. Transparency was documentation without consequence.

The Influence Tactics Breakdown

Grief Bait as Engagement Architecture. Death and terminal illness are the highest-performing emotional content categories on social platforms. The algorithm treats a post generating 100 condolence comments identically to a post generating 100 outrage replies: both signal engagement, both get distributed. The operators chose grief not because they wanted to cause harm — grief is the most reliable high-engagement content type. Harm is a side effect of the business model.

Identity Salience Targeting. The operation selected communities where sports identity is inseparable from cultural, religious, and neighbourhood identity. For Pacific communities in South Auckland or Western Sydney, the local club player is a community member in a genuine sense. Fabricating his death or his wife’s death activates the specific emotional architecture of those communities at maximum intensity. The targeting is not demographic. It is psychographic: find where identity is load-bearing, push on it.

AI Watermarks as Non-Deterrent. The Google Gemini and SynthID watermarks represent the current state of AI disclosure technology: present, visible, insufficient. A watermark embedded in an image is detectable on inspection. Inspection requires intent to inspect. A user who sees a post declaring a beloved player dead doesn’t inspect the image metadata — they comment. The watermark serves a forensic function after the fact. It does not interrupt the grief response in real time.

Transparency Infrastructure as Cover, Not Constraint. Facebook’s Page Transparency system disclosed Vietnamese operators. The pages ran for months after disclosure. Transparency was available; consequences were not. An operator running a financially motivated disinformation page in 2026 can rely on the gap between disclosure and enforcement as operational runway.

Network Mobility Before Intervention. The expansion to New Zealand rugby before Australian platform intervention demonstrates that the network’s operational logic precedes platform response. The operators had already expanded before anyone applied pressure. This structural advantage — the network learns and pivots faster than platforms detect and act — is not unique to this operation. It characterizes every financially motivated content farm that treats individual pages as disposable. The knowledge is the durable asset; the pages are temporary.

The Grief Was Real

When a post declared Nathan Merritt dead, and Redfern All Blacks issued a correction, what happened in between?

People called relatives. People sent messages. People told each other he had died. Some knew him. Some knew his family. The correction arrived, and the relief was real — he’s still alive — but so was the interim period of false grief. That grief was experienced by real people with real relationships to a real man whose illness was real.

The $500,000 donation Roger Tuivasa-Sheck never made — someone saw that post and felt pride, felt gratitude, felt something about their community. Then the correction arrived. The emotional investment was real. The fact was fabricated.

The 100 condolence comments under the Julian Savea post — each one was written by a person who believed someone had died. Each one was also a data point: the post is working, the algorithm is distributing it, keep the link in the comments.

Financially motivated disinformation doesn’t need you to remain deceived. It needs you to engage before you know better. The grief pays on the way in. The correction doesn’t reverse the revenue.

This article is part of Decipon’s Manipulation Breakdowns series, which examines specific influence operations through the Influence Tactics Protocol.

Sources: